You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Pioneer Santa Barbara County winery's request to use offsite grapes may trigger look at ordinances
alert top story

Pioneer Santa Barbara County winery's request to use offsite grapes may trigger look at ordinances

An application from one of Santa Barbara County’s pioneer wineries to use up to 100% of grapes from offsite in its wines earned preliminary approval Wednesday from the Planning Commission and, in the process, planted the seed for potential revisions to the winery ordinances.

On a 4-1 vote, with Commissioner Michael Cooney dissenting, the commission directed the staff to return to the June 24 meeting with findings that Zaca Mesa Winery & Vineyard’s requested modification conforms with provisions of its 1977 conditional use permit.

Cooney said he voted “no” because approving the request might prompt other wineries to make the same case for modifying their operations.

“I think we ought to talk about amending the [winery] ordinances,” he added.

Fourth District Commissioner Larry Ferini indicated the winery ordinances don’t take into account the ongoing changes and economic realities of the industry.

“In 1977 … the wine industry was just a baby … ,” Ferini said. “In that time, everything has changed. What I see now in the wine business, they have to have freedom to evolve or they’re going to perish.”

Fifth District Commissioner Dan Blough agreed: “We do need to have staff look at the ordinances.”

The winery's original permit allowed it to use up to 350 tons of grapes grown off the premises for its annual production of 20,000 cases per year, with a limit of 700 tons of offsite grapes in any five-year period.

“This was a pioneer age of Santa Barbara County wine country,” Zaca Mesa Winery owner Stewart Cushman told commissioners, noting four friends who called themselves “wildcatters” decided to build what would be the fourth winery in the county after planting a vineyard a few years earlier.

“The vast majority of our history, we have processed all of our own fruit,” he said later.

In January, Cushman asked the Planning and Development Department to allow the winery to produce its annual 60,000 cases using only grapes not grown on the winery property, but within Santa Barbara and San Luis Obispo counties.

However, Planning and Development Director Lisa Plowman in February determined findings could not be made for seven of 18 criteria used to show it would substantially conform to the conditions of the original permit.

Planner Delaney Roney told the commission the modification would substantially change the scope and intent of the permit, would likely have an impact on Foxen Canyon Road that was not analyzed in the initial negative environmental declaration and was an operational change to a specific limitation, among other things.

But consultant Lisa Bodrogi of Cuvée Connections disagreed.

“We are not asking for any changes to our operation,” she said, adding the concern in 1977 was that using grapes grown elsewhere would not support local agriculture.

“The intent of the county … was to bolster robust processing capacity based on wine grapes grown in Santa Barbara and San Luis Obispo counties,” she said.

Bodrogi said the company had conducted a traffic study that found the change would have only minimal impact on Foxen Canyon Road, and she noted the winery had no complaints or zoning violations over its 43-year history.

Fifth District Commissioner Dan Blough asked why the concern about the quantity of grapes coming from offsite when most of the wine grapes grown here are sent out of the county.

Alex Tuttle, a Permitting Division supervisor, noted the current winery ordinances require wineries to have a half-acre of grapes onsite for every 1,000 cases produced.

“It’s not so much a philosophical objection to the request, it’s more looking at the regulations and our permitting process and figuring out the best way to move forward with the request,” Tuttle said.

But he admitted at present there was no clear path for Cushman to get what he wanted because of the requirement for using grapes grown onsite.

Commissioner John Parke, whose 3rd District encompasses the winery, moved to have staff bring back findings for substantial conformity at the June 24 meeting.

“What we’ve got here is a wine country pioneer that’s been a model citizen for close to 50 years,” Parke said, adding the owner is simply asking for flexibility to compete with other wineries.


The business news you need

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

News Editor

Mike Hodgson is news editor at the Santa Ynez Valley News, where he writes about local government, special events and the people who live in the Valley. He has been a photographer, writer, news editor and managing editor at weekly newspapers since 1972

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News